Stiller Law Firm has won an anti-SLAPP appeal for Sergeant Steven Heindel of the San Mateo County Sheriff’s Office.
Sergeant Heindel claims that the Sheriff’s Office retailiated against him for speaking up about slow processing times for restraining orders, which put the public at risk. He alleges that, after complaining, he was investigated, placed on administrative leave, and made to undergo psychological exams. He also claims that senior personnel defamed him by telling coworkers he was “crazy” and “mentally unwell” and that they should not speak with him.
The County filed an anti-SLAPP motion aimed at the defamation claim. The anti-SLAPP law protects speech and petitioning on public issues. The County claimed that spreading office rumors that Sergeant Heindel was crazy furthered a public debate about officer safety.
The trial court denied the motion and, on November 16, 2026, the Court of Appeal affirmed. It agreed with Stiller Law Firm’s argument that the County did not show the alleged statements arose in a public context. Although the Sheriff’s Department is a public agency, the remarks were made privately to a handful of coworkers. The record did not show that they added to a public debate about officer safety or training. Sergeant Heindel was awarded his costs on appeal.
Certified Appellate Specialist Ari J. Stiller presented oral argument, video of which can be found here.
Stiller Law Firm is pleased to have served as Sergeant Heindel’s appellate counsel. We wish him success seeking justice at trial.

